Skip to main content

Age Discrimination Claims & Circumstantial Evidence: Attempts to Make a Mountain Out of a Molehill Often Difficult to Prevail Upon


Roberts v. IBM - Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals

Facts: George Roberts worked for IBM and was subsequently fired after a few years at the company and a history of poor work performance.  Notwithstanding the history of poor work performance, Roberts brought an age discrimination claim against IBM and focused on two instances:  1) an instant message between Human Resources managers that talked about Roberts's "shelf life" and 2) the name of IBM's program used to eliminate positions that were not cost effective, labeled "Project Blue."  Roberts argued that the discussion of his "shelf life" was a reference to his age and that the name of IBM's "Project Blue" constituted direct evidence of age discrimination, given that "blue" often referred to older people with blue hair.  The District Court granted summary judgment for IBM.

Holding:  The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals held that Roberts could not succeed on his age discrimination claim and the lower court's grant of summary judgment for IBM was proper.  In essence, the Court found that without direct evidence of age discrimination by IBM, under the McDonnell Douglas burden shifting analysis, Roberts failed to produce sufficient circumstantial evidence to prevail as IBM had a valid nondiscriminatory reason for firing him.

In regard to Roberts's "shelf life" argument, the Court held that this language was at worst an inartful reference to Roberts's amount of billable work.  The Human Resources managers had discussed Roberts's "shelf life" in the context of whether they could justify paying him if there was not enough work, rather than a reference to Roberts's age.  The Court held that this "shelf life" language failed to amount to direct evidence of age discrimination and would qualify, at most, as circumstantial evidence.  Under McDonnell Douglas, even if Roberts's evidence was to be believed, Roberts's poor work performance was a valid nondiscriminatory reason provided by IBM for firing him.

The Court then addressed the "Project Blue" argument and held that, standing alone, the Human Resource department's mention of the color blue in its program could not reasonably be taken as a reference to anyone's age.  In fact, Roberts had not even been discharged as a part of "Project Blue" but instead was fired through a different process several months later.  Consequently, the evidence of "Project Blue" failed to amount to direct evidence of age discrimination.  The Court further held that under McDonnell Douglas, even if Roberts's evidence was to be believed, Roberts's poor work performance was a valid nondiscriminatory reason provided by IBM for firing him.

Judgment: The District Court's grant of summary judgment was affirmed, finding that Roberts had failed to assert a valid age discrimination claim.

Majority Opinion Judge:  Judge Gorsuch

Date:  November 5, 2013

Opinion:  http://www.ca10.uscourts.gov/opinions/12/12-5169.pdf

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

NLRB: Discussion Among Employees About Tip Pooling is Protected Concerted Activity

  This Advice Memorandum from the National Labor Relations Board’s Associate General Counsel, Jayme Sophir, addressed whether employees which discussed and complained about tip pooling at work constituted protected concerted activity. In relevant part, an employer in New York operated a chain of steakhouses.  While tip pooling was in place at these steakhouses, some of the employees objected to it on the grounds that it was not transparent and improperly divided tips among the workers.  Employees were told not to complain or talk to each other about the tip pool and were told that doing so would endanger their jobs.  Despite the employer later attempting to provide some clarity as to how the tips were being divided, rancor still existed among some employees.  At one point, the employees were told by a general manager that some employees that had been talking about the tip pool were “cleared out” and the employer would continue to do so. In the Advice Memorandum,...
Post a Comment
Read more

Breaking: Labor Secretary Rumored to Be Leaving Administration

A few hours ago, word leaked out that Labor Secretary Marty Walsh (“Walsh”) is in the midst of negotiations to head up the NHL Players Union and leave his position at the Labor Department. Walsh, who has served as the sole Labor Secretary under President Biden, has taken part in a labor renaissance of sorts as support for organized labor has increased during his term as Labor Secretary (although the number of workers that have joined a union over the past two years has not grown as mush as some expected.)  He has also overseen the ongoing negotiations with rail workers over a new contract, although that matter is still on shaky ground and playing out as we speak. As for who might step into the vacant Labor Secretary role, there are already rumblings that President Biden should nominate Deputy Labor Secretary Julie Su (a strong labor advocate) or even a progressive like Senator Bernie Sanders.  Until Walsh officially gives his notice, however, I would expect some/many potential...
Post a Comment
Read more

San Diego Rolls Back Vaccine Mandate For City Workers

Last Tuesday, the San Diego City Council voted to do away with the vaccine mandate for city employees. The city’s vaccine mandate that was in place required city workers to get the coronavirus vaccine or risk termination.  Perhaps to this surprise of no one, the city’s policy came under fire with 14 employees being terminated and over 100 other employees resigning.  With the coronavirus subsiding, including in Southern California, the San Diego City Council took action. Now, bear in mind, the repeal of the vaccine mandate does not take place immediately. With that being said, the mandate will be repealed March 8th.  I suppose the question now is, what other cities or regions follow San Diego’s lead? For additional information:   https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/politics/story/2023-01-24/san-diego-repeals-controversial-covid-19-vaccine-mandate-citing-drop-in-cases-hospitalizations
Post a Comment
Read more