Skip to main content

Speculation On Amount of Overtime Worked? Keep Guessing: Not Sufficient for Wage & Hour Claim

Ihegword v. Harris County Hosp. Dist. - 5th Circuit Court of Appeals





Facts:  Edith Ihegword was a nurse at several hospitals in Houston from 1998 to 2009.  In 2009, Ihegword was discharged on the grounds of poor job performance, loss of confidence and inability to get along with co-workers.  Ihegword brought suit and alleged discrimination on the basis of national origin & disability, failure to pay overtime wages in violation of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and Texas Labor Code, and retaliation.  In relevant part, Ihegword claimed that she did not always complete her paperwork to document her time worked before her shift ended.  While she claimed that she maintained a log of her overtime worked, Ihegword said she kept it in her locker but was not allowed to retrieve it after she was terminated.  As a result, Ihegword estimated from memory that she worked about twelve hours of uncompensated overtime a week.   

Harris County Hospital District (HCHD) filed a motion for summary judgment as to all of Ihegword's claims and pointed to Ihegword's deposition testimony in which she claimed to not remember how often she worked overtime and guessed as to the amount of overtime she worked on certain days.  The district court subsequently granted HCHD's motion.  Ihegword appealed to the Court of Appeals. 

Holding:  The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court's ruling and held that there was a complete lack of evidence, other than Ihegword's unsubstantiated speculations from memory as to the amount of overtime hours worked, to support her claim.  As well, the Court of Appeals noted the lower court found that Ihegword failed to produce sufficient evidence that anyone at HCHD knew of the alleged uncompensated overtime Ihegword claimed to have worked.  

Consequently, the Court of Appeals held that unsubstantiated and speculative estimates of uncompensated overtime work does not constitute sufficient evidence to show the amount and extent of that work. 

Judgment:  The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the district court's grant of summary judgment in favor of HCHD, as Ihegword's speculation as to the amount of alleged unpaid overtime worked was insufficient to prevail on her unpaid wages claim.

The Takeaway:  This is a fairly straightforward opinion and one that is not at all surprising.  Employees who claim they were not paid for overtime worked (or even regular, non-overtime work hours) need to have a consistent record of these hours.  Simple guessing or speculation as to the exact amount is not sufficient and will in all likelihood prevent an employee from prevailing on an unpaid wages claim without sufficient, concrete evidence for a court to look to.  

Majority Opinion Judge:  Per Curiam

Date:  February 12, 2014

Opinion:  http://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions%5Cunpub%5C13/13-20186.0.pdf


Thanks to Time Well Spent for the comic.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

NLRB: Discussion Among Employees About Tip Pooling is Protected Concerted Activity

  This Advice Memorandum from the National Labor Relations Board’s Associate General Counsel, Jayme Sophir, addressed whether employees which discussed and complained about tip pooling at work constituted protected concerted activity. In relevant part, an employer in New York operated a chain of steakhouses.  While tip pooling was in place at these steakhouses, some of the employees objected to it on the grounds that it was not transparent and improperly divided tips among the workers.  Employees were told not to complain or talk to each other about the tip pool and were told that doing so would endanger their jobs.  Despite the employer later attempting to provide some clarity as to how the tips were being divided, rancor still existed among some employees.  At one point, the employees were told by a general manager that some employees that had been talking about the tip pool were “cleared out” and the employer would continue to do so. In the Advice Memorandum, it was noted that emplo
Post a Comment
Read more

What I’ve Been Reading This Week

A few years ago, I remember when the “Fight for $15” movement was taking off around the country.  Lo and behold, it appears that a $15/hour minimum wage is not the stopping point, which should be no surprise.  As the below article notes, New York is aggressively moving to ramp up hourly wage rates even higher.  While all the  below articles are worth a read, I called particular attention to that one. As always, below are a couple article that caught my eye this week. Disney World Workers Reject Latest Contract Offer Late last week, it was announced that workers at Disney World had rejected the most recent contract offer from the company, calling on their employer to do better.  As Brooks Barnes at The New York Times writes, the unions that represent about 32,000 workers at Disney World reported their members resoundingly rejected the 5 year contract offer which would have seen workers receive a 10% raise and retroactive increased back pay.  While Disney’s offer would have increased pa
Post a Comment
Read more

Utah Non-Compete Bill Falters in House

Last month, a non-compete bill sponsored by Representative Brian Greene (Republican from Pleasant Grove) & up for vote in the Utah House failed to make it through the Legislature.  The bill sought to ban enforcement of non-competes if they came after a worker was already employed, given no compensation (such as a bonus or promotion) for signing the non-compete, and laid off within six months.  However, by a 22 - 49 vote, the bill was resoundingly defeated after some business groups lobbied to kill the non-compete bill.  One group in particular, The Free Enterprise Utah coalition, argued that the Utah State Legislature should hold off on any changes to non compete laws in the state until a survey about non competes was done among Utah businesses.  Representative Greene had countered this claim and argued that a survey was not needed to show that the current non compete laws in the states allowed many businesses, including some small high tech companies in the state, to per
Post a Comment
Read more